I have used a number of other Noodler's inks mostly in the blue to blue-black spectrum, all with excellent and satisfactory results. I wanted a true, deep black ink of real waterproofness and permanence, for which Noodler's Black has a stellar reputation. I use almost exclusively Tomoe River 52gsm paper, Moleskin level paper, or Rhodia pads with a MontBlanc Le Grande with an Extra Fine nib that writes very wet. My Noodler's blues and blue-blacks have all performed well enough. Given my prior experiences, I didn't even think twice (okay, I did a lot of research before hand) and ordered the big bottle of the ink, quite sure that this was the ink I wanted. I was wrong. It just didn't perform at all for me on any of my three papers I tried, from Rhodia 80gsm, Tomoe River 52gsm, to some Moleskin-grade planner paper. Even testing with other pens, the ink exhibited massive shading to the point of being more brown-grey than a dark, deep black. Dry times matched Goulet's reports. The quality of color saturation was so drastic that I tried a number of things to remedy it, including different pens, shaking the bottle, and different papers, all to the same effect. My comparison ink for this is the current pen I'm stuck with for this task until I find a black that works for me: the Uniball Vision 0.7mm Fine. The Montblanc laid down a line about the same size, or maybe 0-.8mm, but with about half the saturation, if that, with nowhere near the crispness or contrast. It was the copy paper that finally delivered an ink that could be considered black. It was more of a brownish black, but it was at least black,. There was some feathering, but not as much as some of the blues and blue blacks on similar papers from the same pens. Overall, the performance of this ink improved as the paper became more absorbant and less "fountain pen friendly." My guess is that somewhere in the cream moleskin or just below that level of paper would net some of the best results with this ink. Otherwise the pen isn't going to write a very good, black line. If you like a more sepia or desaturated color, then this is what you get with this Black on papers like Rhodia and Tomoe River IME. This experience coincides with the following analysis: http://macchiatoman.com/blog/2017/12/11/ink-comparison-32-black-inksThe ink is relatively waterproof and resistant. However, when I did a comparison of this ink laid on Rhodia paper against some prior paper that I had inked with Uni-ball Vision Super Ink and J Herbin Enre Authentique inks, the difference was readily apparent. The other pigmented inks were more rub-resistant, stayed absolutely clear, maintained all their color, and didn't run at all. The Noodler's Black had insignificant run, rubbed off much easier, and generally didn't maintain the same level of color saturation when wet. However, it was most definitely adhered to the page in a way that would qualify as Buletproof, so it *is* waterproof and long lasting, but the difference in "quality of image" with this ink and the others was very obvious. Given all of this, it's likely that I will not be using this ink myself. I'm going to relegate it for use as an inexpensive but functional fountain pen ink for my children who have more opportunities to deal with absorbent papers in some of their workbooks, and for which having a dye-based waterproof ink will be useful when doing some of their drawing and writing, without breaking the bank or introducing a heavy maintenance ritual that a pigmented ink might require. Overall, for all the hype that this ink receives, and comparing it to the performance of some of the other inks from Noodler's that I have tried, I find the juice is nowhere near worth the squeeze, and it's barely average among waterproof inks when compared to other available options. It appears that the Iron Gall based Montblanc Permanent Black will perform better with minimal maintenance requirements, and pigmented inks potentially even better at the cost of more maintenance. Uni-ball Vision rollerball ink performs better for me across a wider array of papers than this ink does as well. I can recommend this ink for people working with absorbent paper of reasonably high-quality who need a waterproof/bulletproof type ink who want or need a dye-based cellulose-reactive ink over an Iron Gall or Pigmented ink, and who are more interested in the durability of the ink than the vibrancy of the color. If any of these limitations changes, then I believe there are much better ink and paper options available, IME.